A Persistent—and Growing—Public Safety Issue
Dogs are overwhelmingly viewed as companions—family members, protectors, and emotional supports. Yet beneath that cultural reality lies a far more troubling truth: data from federal health sources show that dogs kill roughly 30 to 50 people per year in the United States, with an average of about 43 deaths annually.
At least, those were the numbers.
Unfortunately, recent reporting and research suggest that fatalities are trending upward, particularly following the COVID-19 pandemic, when dog ownership surged and more interactions occurred in home environments. CDC data shows a 174% increase in deaths from 2018 to 2023. Annual fatalities rose from 48 in 2019 to 98 in 2022, a dramatic rise linked to increased pet ownership and interaction.
Dog attack fatalities in the United States reached record highs in 2025, marking four consecutive years of rising fatal attacks. The usual suspect — pit bulls — were involved in roughly 70% of deaths. As of early 2026, 2025 data shows at least 84-87 fatal attacks occurred, indicating a sharp increase since the pandemic.
So what’s causing this increase?
Patterns in Fatal Attacks
All signs point toward increasing mismanagement, neglect, and increasingly careless behavior on the part of pet owners, who allow the certain dogs to come into contact with the most vulnerable victims.
Several consistent patterns emerge across fatal dog attack data:
- Vulnerable populations: Young children (especially ages 1–4) and elderly adults are disproportionately represented among victims.
- Multiple-dog attacks: A growing share of fatalities involve two or more dogs acting in a pack, sometimes overwhelming victims in seconds.
- Known dogs: Many victims are attacked by dogs they know—family pets, neighbors’ dogs, or animals under the care of acquaintances.
- Environment matters: A significant number of fatal attacks occur on private property, often where dogs are inadequately restrained or socialized.
These are not random encounters in the wild—they are frequently predictable, preventable failures of containment, training, or supervision.
A Case Study in Extreme Violence
We’ve handled seemingly every kind of dog bite case: amputation, near-death encounters. A recent attack was a particularly disturbing example—captured in widely circulated footage.
In that incident, three dogs attacked and killed a woman, then remained at the scene and reportedly began consuming her remains. When police arrived, the dogs displayed defensive, territorial behavior—guarding what they perceived as a food source.
Here’s a link to the video.
This illustrates how quickly these situations can escalate beyond control.
While such extreme post-attack behavior is rare, it underscores several important realities:
- Dogs can revert to predatory instincts, especially in pack dynamics
- Once a fatal attack begins, it can be difficult or impossible to interrupt without lethal force
- The line between domesticated pet and dangerous animal can collapse under certain conditions
What Makes Certain Attacks Fatal?
Experts point to a combination of factors contributing to fatal dog attacks:
1. Increased Dog Ownership
The pandemic-era rise in pet ownership led to more dogs in households, often without adequate training or socialization.
2. Poor Containment and Neglect
Many fatal incidents involve dogs that were:
- improperly confined
- allowed to roam
- previously aggressive or reported
3. Multi-Dog “Pack” Dynamics
When multiple dogs act together, aggression can escalate dramatically, with each dog reinforcing the others’ behavior.
4. Owner Misjudgment
A recurring theme in fatal cases is the belief that “my dog would never do that”—even when warning signs exist.
The Legal and Policy Implications
These incidents raise difficult legal questions:
- Should stricter liability standards apply to dog owners in state like Pennsylvania, which does not have full strict liability (yet) for all dog bites in all cases, except when it comes to liability for medical bills?
- Are current “dangerous dog” criminal fines sufficient—or too reactive?
- Do breed-specific regulations help (though none exist in PA), or distract from owner responsibility?
Courts across the country continue to grapple with these issues, particularly in cases involving prior warnings, inadequate restraint, or multiple dogs.
Conclusion
While still rare compared to the roughly 4.5 million dog bites annually, the severity of fatal attacks—and the often gruesome circumstances surrounding them—has intensified public concern. Fatal dog attacks remain rare—but they are not random, and they are not unavoidable. The data shows a consistent baseline of deaths each year, with indications of an upward trend in certain periods.
The horrifying case of dogs killing a woman and then guarding her body is not representative of most dog behavior—but it is a stark reminder of what can happen when those risk factors align.
At its core, this is not just an animal issue. It is a human responsibility issue—one that sits at the intersection of public safety, law, and the limits of domestication.
Contact Us Today!
Our lawyers help the families of those who lost a loved one to vicious animal attack. Contact us today to learn how a wrongful death and survival action works in PA.
412.400.5476